Colin Parkinson
Army.ca Myth
- Reaction score
- 12,390
- Points
- 1,160
Both the Taliban and ISIS in Iraq prepared the ground, by secret negotiations, intimidation, murder and marriage. they "shaped the battle" before it started.
Consolidation sounds nice, but one needs an army that will actually fight for that to happen.
Otherwise the taliban will do what napoleon did, and win simply by marching.
You said the IRoA should leave the south and consolidate around the capital.I think you ignored a large portion of my post but I'll re-state it....
The Taliban never controlled all of Afghanistan, even at the height of their power from 1996-2001. The Afghan Army is incapable of holding on to the entire Country but they still have capable fighting units and can control parts of the Country.
I don't think the Taliban will be able to control the entire Country and we will enter a long period of protracted civil war.
I think you ignored a large portion of my post but I'll re-state it....
The Taliban never controlled all of Afghanistan, even at the height of their power from 1996-2001. The Afghan Army is incapable of holding on to the entire Country but they still have capable fighting units and can control parts of the Country.
I don't think the Taliban will be able to control the entire Country andwethey will enter a long period of protracted civil war.
Absolutely not, the Colonial constructs of artificially drawn lines must be maintained at all costs. It's really funny to see people complain of colonialism and then defend the current borders or demand that the Golan be returned to Syria because of two colonialists said that it was a good idea to put a line there.In Afghanistan do they think about splitting the country along Tajik/Pashtun lines and would that even help?
That didn’t take long. Murderers. I cannot express adequately my absolute loathing for the Taliban.Video is surfacing of a group of 10 Afghan commandos being executed after surrendering to the taliban. War crime o'clock apparently in Afghanistan today.
FUNKER530 | Military Videos and News
Funker530: Combat footage and military news for the veteran community.funker530.com
As the Taliban retakes Afghanistan, a sense of disastrous déjà vu
Kabul by Christmas.
Which is where we were, Kabul at Christmas, 2001, when the Taliban had just been toppled, ousted by an intense bombing campaign led by American and British forces, with the brutal regime’s Al Qaeda “guests’’ in disarray and on the run.
With the 20th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks looming, the U.S. has extricated itself from its longest foreign war — in an unseemly military scramble for the exits — the Brits and NATO have bugged out, and Afghanistan is teetering on the precipice of disastrous déjà vu.
Leaving behind the vast Bagram airfield outside the capital, with thousands of civilian trucks and hundreds of armoured vehicles just sitting there. A ghost-base, hastily evacuated and handed over to Afghan forces, awaiting scavenging by the Taliban.
Leaving behind, too, a litany of broken promises — the assurance, from the West, that Afghanistan would never be abandoned again…
Within hours of Bagram being vacated, the Taliban was on the march, surging and expanding their reach, with only the Afghan air force to check their advance. They captured hundreds of rural districts in the north and surrounded the capital of Badakhshan, with upwards of 1,000 Afghan troops — demoralized and poorly equipped — fleeing their posts, crossing a river bridge into bordering Tajikistan. Hundreds more — Afghan army, police and intelligence troops — laid down their weapons and surrendered when their positions were overwhelmed…
“Rumours are being published that the Taliban are imposing restrictions or even a complete ban on media, people and women in the newly liberated areas,’’ Taliban spokesman Zabihullah Mujahid said in a statement released last week. “We reject such propaganda. All schools are fully open, the media is allowed to operate in a free and neutral manner within Islamic rules, clinics and health centres are able to work without any constraints. Civil servants, journalists can also live and perform their duties without fear.’’
Right. Pull the other one.
This was the fundamentalist regime that banned music and television, forced men to grow their beards, executed, threw suspected homosexuals off rooftops and conducted public executions for those caught breaking Taliban edicts.
…there’s no hope for Afghans. They’re doomed, even as the Taliban says it will present a written peace proposal to the government as soon as next month at the stalled negotiations in Doha. The U.S. has repeatedly sought neighbouring Pakistan’s help to convince the insurgents to deliver a written plan. But Pakistan is treacherous. It incubated the Taliban and its regional aspirations have long relied on the Taliban. This is, after all, the country that sheltered Osama bin Laden, its denials not worth a fig.
My fixer, driver and friend for nearly two decades, sends desperate texts. “I need to get my family out. They’ll come for the interpreters first. Please can you help?’’
He’s been an interpreter for NATO for years.
Canada’s combat mission in Afghanistan ended in 2011, transitioning to a training mission. Ottawa has said it will take in hundreds of vulnerable Afghans, interpreters, embassy staff and their families. The U.S. has promised to relocate thousands of interpreters by next month. Which might be too late.
I’m sorry Faramaz. I’m so sorry.
Rosie DiManno is a Toronto-based columnist covering sports and current affairs for the Star. Follow her on Twitter: @RDiManno
Opinion | As the Taliban retakes Afghanistan, a sense of disastrous déjà vu
I certainly hope this lights a fire under the fat asses of the bureaucrats who are stalling about the immigration of some of the interpreters that our military employed.
I've stayed in touch with an interpreter on and off over the years. He said the Taliban is even going after people who worked for NATO 15 years ago.For anyone with Facebook, the page “Canadian Afghanistan War Veterans Association” has informative updates from historian/correspondent Sean Maloney. He’s working contacts he still has on the ground... It’s grim.
I've stayed in touch with an interpreter on and off over the years. He said the Taliban is even going after people who worked for NATO 15 years ago.