I'm not familiar with the Oakley pilot gloves, however, if they're anything like other pilot gloves in general then they are likely not as durable as these blackhawk gloves. I remember about eight to ten years ago the wearing of pilot gloves among infantrymen was fairly common. This was before there was a large ammount of commercial tactical gloves to choose from. They were very comfortable and provided great dexterity but at reduced durability.
I used two pairs of the Fury Commando gloves in Kandahar. Around five months in small holes began forming on the thumb and index fingers, but didn't become a problem until month seven. They endured 12 to 18 hour days in summer heat in a frontline role. So I'd give em a high rating. After tour I cut the fingers off and now use them as range gloves as the palms and cuffs are still great.
Hope that helps.