- Reaction score
- 4,272
- Points
- 1,260
Need this tooAs with everything we need to do, all it takes is money and political will.
Need this tooAs with everything we need to do, all it takes is money and political will.
I wasnt thinking so much as housing but just a couple 200x400 here and there, like extra arenasPart of the issue is the numbers but also the erratic areas where folks come from. Do you build housing for 3? 5? 20,000 people in a Whitehorse/Grande Prairie/Sioux Lookout/Tutuyuktuk? That might be double the size of some communities and they don't have just the shortage of housing but also sewer/medical/groceries etc. in town to support them. It's why you'll hear of remote, fly in communities in Northern Ontario being scattered from Kenora/Thunder Bay/Sault Ste. Marie/Toronto as the hotel rooms alone limit how much can be done.
That negative aside there has been temporary camps set up (Slave Lake 2011) or use of industrial camps (Fort Mac 2016) for examples where folks were given a safe spot until a longer term solution can be created. It's not so bad in July/August where there are more empty schools/arenas that can be used but it's really tough in April when Universities and public schools are still in use.
Solutions?
- prioritize road building to connect these remote communities. Even a single lane road + airstrip allows for dual options for escape vs. a single airstrip...especially if it's a gravel strip. It also has the potential to allow for a big drop in cost of living due to the ability to truck in essentials like groceries vs. airlift everything. This doesn't mean everything connects (my wallet just shrunk thinking about how much that'd cost) but would be an evacuation route to a second alternative location...think Fort Mac in 2016 moving residents north to the camps/airstrips up there as an interim measure until either airlift or conditions changed to allow road egress.
- It may be appropriate to look at planning wider for emergency response than just provinces. Is High Level a local evac center or is it also the next major community for anyone evacuating from the NWT? Fort Nelson is the next major center from the Yukon via Alaska Highway. Start with a large gravel pad where a temporary camp could be set up if needed + fuel bowser + power supply. A series of pre-established staging areas might be the low cost option so that WHEN the region needs to evacuate folks know they can a) refuel vehicles regardless of budget b) have a safe place to pull over and rest c) can be an interim assembly areas for families separated and d) a solid location for an Incident Command Post/Base camp for accommodations if needed. This however would need to have all the billing pre-established so that a small town knows in advance the bill is being pad by the neighboring area/agency/town.
I tend to think in about 5 hour radius travel circles as that is "roughly" a tank of gas. IF you're in a place like Northern Ontario with longer gaps between major communities then it's a case of road hubs (including gravel options) for your mid point location. But key here is low ongoing maintenance costs as least to start.
Longer term I often think of what would happen if the CAF and Canadian Universities both went on major "dorm/barracks" housing builds. Towers of multiple bedroom "quarters" that would serve a multiple purpose role of a) reducing some of the rent pressures on CAF members if they knew there were SQ/PMQ available at a common rent rate regardless of posting b) pull some of the student housing pressure off of communities and c) in case of emergency allow for use of vacant rooms for evacuees.
I can dream of winning the lotto Max jackpot too .
foresterab
I've spent nights in arenas...and they're okay if nothing else is available. But like you I was thinking shelter areas where - for example - a series of ranger tents and cots could be set up (beats sleeping in a truck) or a portable camp brought in.I wasnt thinking so much as housing but just a couple 200x400 here and there, like extra arenas
Need this tooAs with everything we need to do, all it takes is money and political will.
Fires in the Flin Flon area are smoking us out in the south. Visibility is about a mile and less in some spots
From which? Fort Nelson is about 3300 people and logically evacs to Fort St John, maybe a five hour drive?
When I got up this morning when I stepped out I thought at first one of my neighbors were on fire .Fires in the Flin Flon area are smoking us out in the south. Visibility is about a mile and less in some spots
Evacuees are spreading further and further out due to lack of capacity in FSJ. It's not as simple as directing someone to the next town but where would they be able to establish for days/weeks?
To follow up on the earlier discussion on evacuation and capacity:
Evacuees are spreading further and further out due to lack of capacity in FSJ. It's not as simple as directing someone to the next town but where would they be able to establish for days/weeks?
foresterab
the only time i was in a camp everyone had there own room and 2 rooms shared a bathroom in between them.It's been a long time since I've worked in NE BC and I'm not up to speed on where are all the camps at the moment. I remember quite a few that were good for 20-50 men(2 x room) and depending on where located it's pretty amazing how fast the camp companies can bring in housing for 100? 200? 400? people in hours...not days...literally hours if you're willing to pay the price.
If it's Fort Mac area that's a whole different set of options available for camps there or within the region and it's not 20-50 man camps but 1,500-9,500 man camps depending on what is going on for activity/ what facilities are shut down and many of the large projects also have their own private paved airstrips capable of 737 traffic making airlift much more flexible if needed.
That being said being evacuated sucks and not something I'd wish on any person or family.
My first reaction to this was a very flippant "let them eat pancakes", but upon further reflection I can see how for the average Canadian being told "no, we don't have and can't get that" is a major shock.Mounting pressure on communities receiving evacuees...
Burgers run out, hotels heave, as wildfire evacuees swell a BC town
The Denny’s restaurant in Fort St. John, B.C., ran out of burgers on Tuesday, a waiter said.
Hotels have been filled with new guests, some turning up without identification or money, according to one manager. Fort St. John businesses have been doing their best to welcome the influx, offering free movie nights — popcorn included — and discount burritos.
The community in northeastern B.C. is heaving with evacuees from Fort Nelson, a further 380 kilometres north, since residents were ordered to get out Friday in the face of a fast−growing wildfire.
Rob Fraser, the mayor of the Northern Rockies Regional Municipality, which includes Fort Nelson, pleaded for patience from evacuees as they settled in.
In a video posted to Facebook this week, he said Fort St. John had to absorb the "shock" of about 3,500 people dropping "into a community of 25,000."
Evacuees packed the parking lot of the North Peace Arena Wednesday after a meeting to explain their situation, many leaving with maps in their hands showing the fires’ locations, spreading out to hotels that have had to absorb thousands of unexpected guests.
Fraser said the fires burning near their community leave the future in the short−term "up in the air," and there is no solid timeline for when residents can return.
Burgers run out, hotels heave, as wildfire evacuees swell a BC town
The Denny’s restaurant in Fort St. John, B.C., ran out of burgers on Tuesday, a waiter said. Hotels have been filled with new guests, some tu.www.victorianow.com
My first reaction to this was a very flippant "let them eat pancakes", but upon further reflection I can see how for the average Canadian being told "no, we don't have and can't get that" is a major shock.
Hopefully those who have been evacuated can find some comfort while things get sorted.