- Reaction score
- 4,029
- Points
- 1,260
From Hansard (exchange also attached if link doesn't work):
* - Yes, I KNOW "not allowing the BQ to speak in this case" =/= "not allowing Quebec to be heard in general", but I suspect the BQ's messaging isn't going to be quite that nuanced.
I know rules are rules, but doesn't this give the BQ more ammo re: their "Quebec isn't listened to/allowed to speak" messaging? *.... Mr. Louis Plamondon (Bas-Richelieu—Nicolet—Bécancour, BQ): Mr. Speaker, on behalf of the Bloc Québécois and all of its members, I would also like to pay tribute to our veterans. I rise here today to recognize Veterans' Week. It is very important to commemorate—
The Speaker: The hon. member must have unanimous consent to respond to a minister's statement. Does the House give unanimous consent?
Some hon. members: Agreed.
Some hon. members: No.
The Speaker: There is no consent.
Hon. Bob Rae: Mr. Speaker, I rise on a point of order. Let the record show that when a member of the House rose to pay tribute to the veterans of our country on behalf of his political party, a party with which I do not agree, the members of the Conservative Party would not allow that member to speak. It is shameful that there are people in this House who do not want to hear the opinions of others. It is shameful.
Mr. Stephen Woodworth: Mr. Speaker, I want to raise an objection to what the member just said. There is no question that I said nothing in response to the request for unanimous consent. I do not know how many of my colleagues over here did or did not. It is inappropriate for the member to make that a partisan comment by referencing the members on this side of the House.
The Speaker: Order, please. The Chair sought the consent of the House and consent was not given.
Mr. Louis Plamondon: Mr. Speaker, I would like to seek unanimous consent once again, as dean of this House, as a member of this House. Like all other members, I would like to pay tribute to veterans on behalf of the four members of my party. I also ask on behalf of the Green Party. I do not see this as a partisan act. I see it simply as a noble gesture in order to say to those individuals who went and fought, and those who gave their lives, that we pay tribute to them. How is it that I cannot get unanimous consent? This is not meant to be a precedent that I will use any other time. Today is a special day. That is all. I simply want to pay tribute to veterans, like everyone else, as we have always done. I am seeking unanimous consent and I appeal to the Conservative members to grant it. It is only fair. The minister said in his speech that this House is a symbol of our freedom and democracy. He said that. I think I should have the right to speak.
Hon. Gordon O'Connor: Mr. Speaker, the Standing Orders say, in response to a minister's statement, that only members of recognized parties can make statements. The Bloc is not a recognized party ....
* - Yes, I KNOW "not allowing the BQ to speak in this case" =/= "not allowing Quebec to be heard in general", but I suspect the BQ's messaging isn't going to be quite that nuanced.